UnitedRenewalsGet free quotes
Hiring a Pro

How to Compare Contractor Quotes

Reviewed by the United Renewals editorial team · How we source these figures · Last updated: November 2026

Advertising disclosure: United Renewals is free to use. We may be compensated when you request quotes through our partners, which can affect which offers appear. See “How We Make Money” in our footer for full details.

Compare quotes by the line items, not only the total. Consumer Reports says to request bids from at least three roofing pros. [54] GAF says to meet at least 3 contractors and get itemized written estimates. [53] NCOA says to get at least three estimates on the same specifications, including for a walk-in tub. [55]

How many quotes, according to the pages that say so

There is no single federal number. These are the counts the cited pages actually print.

Consumer Reports’ roofing buying guide says to request bids from at least three pros, because the price can vary even when the same shingles are installed. [54] GAF’s roofer checklist says to meet with at least 3 contractors and ask for estimates in writing. [53] NCOA’s aging-in-place contractor guide says to get at least three cost estimates from three companies, and to hand each one the same job specifications. [55] United Renewals’ own vetting page says the same thing: at least three written, itemized quotes. See how we vet contractors.

NRCA’s selecting-a-contractor page does not print a count. It says to insist on a written proposal and to keep a healthy skepticism about the lowest bid. [51]

Roof worksheet

Copy these rows from NRCA’s proposal list, GAF’s checklist, and Consumer Reports’ bid breakdown. Leave a cell blank when the quote does not say. Do not fill a blank with a price from another house.

NRCA says a proposal should name the roof covering, manufacturer, and color; the materials; the scope; whether the existing roof is removed or replaced; flashing; ventilation; who fixes landscape or interior damage; the installation method; start and completion dates; payment procedures; and what the warranty covers. [52] GAF says the estimate should itemize labor, materials, permit fees, prep, cleanup, and disposal, and should name underlayment, ventilation, payment terms, and warranties. [53] Consumer Reports says to separate the shingle price, the labor to remove and install, and a contingency if sheathing has to be replaced, and to ask for a workmanship warranty in writing. [54]

Roof lineQuote 1Quote 2Quote 3
Roof covering, manufacturer, and color
Tear-off or overlay
Underlayment
Flashing
Ventilation
Decking or sheathing allowance
Labor, separate from materials
Permit, prep, cleanup, and disposal
Who repairs landscape or interior damage
Start and completion dates
Payment schedule
Workmanship warranty and manufacturer warranty

Rows only. The cells stay empty on purpose. Write what each quote says.

Window worksheet

Use the same rule: one scope, written lines, three columns. How to choose a window installer already says the quote should name the brand, the glass package, and whether the job is an insert or a full-frame replacement. The window replacement cost guide is the price check, not a fill-in for a missing line.

Window lineQuote 1Quote 2Quote 3
Brand and product line
Frame material
Glass package
Insert or full-frame
Number of windows
Trim, haul-away, and cleanup
Permit
Installation warranty and product warranty
Payment schedule

Rows only. No sample prices.

Bath and shower worksheet

NCOA’s guide covers aging-in-place work, including replacing a bathtub with a walk-in tub. It says the estimates have to describe the same job, and the contract should include the budget, the schedule, payment terms, and how change orders work. [55] Check the lines against the bathroom remodel, bathtub, walk-in tub, tub-to-shower, or walk-in shower guide for the job you actually specified.

Bath or shower lineQuote 1Quote 2Quote 3
Product: tub, shower, or conversion
Demo and haul-away
Plumbing stays or moves
Surround, pan, or glass
Permit
Payment terms
Change-order terms

Rows only. Same specifications on every quote, which is the NCOA instruction.

Siding worksheet

How to choose a siding contractor says a written quote should spell out tear-off, house wrap, flashing, trim, and cleanup. The siding cost guide is where the published material bands live. This table does not add a price.

Siding lineQuote 1Quote 2Quote 3
Material and brand
Tear-off of the old siding
House wrap or weather barrier
Flashing and trim
Cleanup and disposal
Permit
Workmanship warranty and product warranty
Payment schedule

Rows only.

Red flags the cited pages name

  • GAF flags an estimate significantly lower than the others, high-pressure sales tactics, and a request for full payment upfront or before the job is done. [53]
  • NRCA says to stay skeptical of the lowest bid. [51]
  • NCOA calls a quote that is significantly less than the others a red flag, because the contractor may be cutting corners or the offer may be a scam. [55]
  • Consumer Reports says labor and the other materials, not the shingle brand alone, are what to watch when the bids diverge. [54]

Payment schedule

NCOA says most professionals ask for an initial payment when you sign, typically 10% of the total, though it can be higher if you are ordering pricey materials, and says never agree to 100% up front. [55] Pay the last invoice when you are satisfied and you have the paperwork. [55]

GAF lists a request for full payment upfront, or before the job is completed, as a red flag. [53] NRCA says the written proposal should include the payment procedures. [51] Put the schedule in the contract before any money moves. How it works covers the quote request. It does not set a contractor’s deposit.

If you are still choosing where to request the quotes, the trade-offs among Angi, HomeAdvisor, Modernize, Thumbtack, Networx, and United Renewals are in how free quote sites work.

Frequently asked questions

How many contractor quotes should I get?

Consumer Reports says at least three roofing bids. [54] GAF says at least 3 written estimates. [53] NCOA says at least three estimates on the same specifications. [55] NRCA does not print a number. It says to require a written proposal and not to trust the lowest bid on price alone. [51]

What should I compare besides the total?

The line items: what is being removed, what materials are named, who pulls the permit, what the warranty covers, and when you pay. A blank line is a question, not a discount.

How much should I pay upfront?

NCOA says an initial payment is typically 10% of the total, higher if materials are expensive, and that you should not agree to pay 100% up front. [55] GAF treats a demand for full payment before the work is done as a red flag. [53] This guide does not print a deposit cap of its own.

Does this apply to a walk-in tub?

NCOA’s aging-in-place contractor guide includes replacing a bathtub with a walk-in tub. It says to get at least three estimates on the same specifications, and to treat a much lower quote as a red flag. [55]

Keep reading

More in Hiring a Pro

Ready to get contractor quotes?

Get matched with vetted, licensed local pros and compare free, no-obligation quotes.

100% free · No obligation · Licensed & vetted pros

Other projects worth pricing

Most homeowners bundle exterior work while the crew and access equipment are already on site — it usually costs less than booking each job separately. Quotes are free and carry no obligation.

Sources

A superscript marks a figure or claim that the linked page states. Figures without a superscript were not matched to a public source. The full list of what we checked is on the cost data methodology page.

  1. [54] Roofing Buying Guide — Consumer Reports. Retrieved 2026-11-22. Updated October 13, 2026. “How Do You Choose a Roofer?” says to request bids from at least three pros. It says to ask for a breakdown: one price for the shingles, one for the labor to remove the old ones and install the new ones, and a contingency budget if sheathing or other materials need to be replaced. It says to ask for a workmanship warranty in writing, separate from the manufacturer’s. The same page also prints asphalt price bands per square. Those dollar bands are not used on United Renewals pages that cite this guide.
  2. [53] Checklist for Choosing the Right Roofer — GAF. Retrieved 2026-11-22. PDF marked ©2023 GAF. Step 4: meet with at least 3 contractors and ask for estimates in writing. Estimates should be itemized and outline the steps, with examples labor, materials, permit fees, prep, clean up, and disposal. The estimate should also include recommended materials (shingles, underlayment, ventilation), payment terms and schedule, and warranties. Red flags: an estimate significantly lower than the others, high-pressure sales tactics, and a request for full payment upfront or before the job is completed. The checklist does not print prices. A footnote says GAF-certified contractors are not employees or agents of GAF.
  3. [55] How to Hire a Contractor for Aging in Place Home Modifications — National Council on Aging. Retrieved 2026-11-22. The opening lists replacing a bathtub with a walk-in tub among aging-in-place jobs. It says to solicit at least three cost estimates from three different professionals or companies, and to give each the exact same job specifications. A quote significantly less than the others is called a huge red flag. The contract section says most professionals ask for an initial payment when you sign, typically 10% of the total, though it could be higher if you are ordering pricey materials or equipment, and says never agree to 100% payment up front. It says the statement of work should include the budget, a project schedule, payment terms, and what happens with change orders. It says to make the final payment once you are satisfied and have the documents.
  4. [51] Selecting a Contractor — National Roofing Contractors Association. Retrieved 2026-11-22. NRCA says to prequalify roofing contractors. Check for a permanent place of business, a phone number, a tax identification number, and a business license where required. Ask for liability insurance and workers’ compensation certificates in effect through the job. Ask for client references and completed projects. Insist on a written proposal with complete descriptions of the work and specifications, plus start and completion dates and payment procedures. Keep a healthy skepticism about the lowest bid. The page does not say “get three quotes” and does not print prices.
  5. [52] Roofing guidelines: resources (what a proposal should include) — National Roofing Contractors Association. Retrieved 2026-11-22. Asked how to choose among three significantly different proposals, NRCA lists items a proposal should include: type of roof covering, manufacturer, and color; materials included; scope of work; removal or replacement of the existing roof; flashing; ventilation; who repairs exterior landscape or interior finishes damaged during the work; installation method; approximate starting and completion dates; payment procedures; length of warranty and what is covered. It says a manufacturer warranty generally covers manufacturing defects and a contractor workmanship warranty covers installation. It says many contractors offer one or two years and there is no industry standard. It does not print a price.