CertainTeed vs. Malarkey Shingles: Which Should You Choose?
Advertising disclosure: United Renewals is free to use. We may be compensated when you request quotes through our partners, which can affect which offers appear. See “How We Make Money” in our footer for full details.
Get free quotes from vetted local roofers
Get free quotesTwo brands with real material innovation stories
This is a comparison between two manufacturers that each lead with a genuine material-technology story rather than just market share. Malarkey's NEX asphalt is polymer-modified (SBS rubberized) rather than standard asphalt, incorporating recycled tire rubber and plastic — the company markets this as delivering meaningfully greater strength and granule adhesion than unmodified asphalt shingles. CertainTeed's Landmark leans on its copper-infused StreakFighter granules, which slowly release copper ions with each rainfall to resist algae growth over the shingle's lifespan.
CertainTeed vs. Malarkey at a glance
| CertainTeed (Landmark) | Malarkey (Legacy) | |
|---|---|---|
| Signature technology | StreakFighter copper-based algae-resistant granules | NEX polymer-modified (rubberized SBS) asphalt with recycled content |
| Standard wind rating | 110 mph, 15-year wind warranty | 110 mph Limited Wind Warranty |
| Enhanced wind rating | Upgradeable tier — confirm conditions locally | 130 mph Enhanced Wind Warranty with qualifying accessories |
| Sustainability angle | Copper-based algae protection | Recycled rubber/plastic content in the asphalt itself |
| Availability | Sold nationally | Historically central/western U.S.; owner (Holcim) expanding east via a new 2026 Indiana plant |
| Ownership | Part of Saint-Gobain | Owned by Holcim since a 2022 acquisition |
Pro tip from our network contractors
Malarkey's regional availability has historically stopped short of the East Coast, but its parent company Holcim is actively building a major new plant in Indiana specifically to expand eastward distribution. If Malarkey isn't available through your local dealers today, it's worth checking again in the near future rather than assuming it's permanently unavailable in your area.
How to actually decide
If a sustainability angle matters to you specifically — recycled material content in the shingle itself, not just the packaging — Malarkey's NEX asphalt is a genuinely distinctive selling point in the category. If you want a widely available national brand with a strong track record and a specific algae-resistance technology, CertainTeed's Landmark is the safer bet for availability, especially outside Malarkey's traditional core region. Confirm both a specific dealer's current stock and each brand's top-tier warranty requirements before deciding. See roof moss and algae removal for more on the algae problem both brands are addressing.
Compare free quotes from vetted local roofers
Get free quotesFrequently asked questions
What is Malarkey's NEX asphalt?
NEX is Malarkey's polymer-modified (SBS rubberized) asphalt formula, which incorporates recycled tire rubber and plastic. The company markets it as delivering greater strength and granule adhesion than standard, unmodified asphalt shingles.
Is Malarkey available everywhere in the U.S.?
Historically, Malarkey has been sold mainly in the central and western U.S. Its owner, Holcim, is building a new plant in Indiana explicitly to expand distribution eastward, so availability is evolving — check with a local dealer for current status in your area.
Who owns Malarkey Roofing?
Malarkey was acquired by Holcim, a global building-materials company, in a 2022 deal valued at $1.35 billion. CertainTeed, by comparison, is part of Saint-Gobain.
What is CertainTeed's StreakFighter technology?
StreakFighter granules contain copper, which releases ions with each rainfall to resist the growth of algae that causes dark streaking on roofs — a long-term protective mechanism built into the shingle's surface.
Keep reading
Ready to get roofing quotes?
Get matched with vetted, licensed local pros and compare free, no-obligation quotes.
100% free · No obligation · Licensed & vetted pros
Other projects worth pricing
Most homeowners bundle exterior work while the crew and access equipment are already on site — it usually costs less than booking each job separately. Quotes are free and carry no obligation.